Courage, Family, Healing, Identity, Judaism, Lessons

An Open Letter to Ivanka Trump from One Daughter to Another

open letterDear Ms. Trump,

I, too, am a daughter of a complex if not difficult man, a man who, while he had loyal friends, trusted colleagues and loving family, was not universally understood or appreciated. He is no longer alive but, if he were, he might agree with some of your father’s political positions. I watched with curiosity as you introduced your father to the Republican National Convention. In addition to your poise, what struck me is your deep love and admiration for the man whose last name you bear. No doubt he’s a light of your life. Your speech moved me, not as a voter but as a daughter who wasn’t able to articulate to my dad how much he meant to me when I still had the chance.

My father wasn’t thrilled with this country’s immigration policies, especially toward Latin Americans, even though he arrived as a refugee in 1950 fleeing communist Hungary and his own path to citizenship had not been a cakewalk. He didn’t want the United States to be soft on dictators or terrorists given that he’d lost his entire family to Nazi atrocities and barely survived the Holocaust. Versions of some of his tirades, delivered around the dinner table or while driving in the car, are now repeated, with less nuance and to a much larger audience, by your father. I’m familiar with and understand why some people are sympathetic to your father’s views even if I don’t hold them myself.

As a convert to Judaism, I imagine you are familiar with Jewish teachings on compassionate speech as well as the teaching that children are not responsible for sins of their fathers. Therefore I am not going to waste time, insult your intelligence, indulge the secular celebration of snark or hop aboard the (justifiable) rage train barreling through the nation by chronicling every single thing your father has said that my own dad, despite being unabashedly politically incorrect at times, would have found beyond the pale. I simply want to say that dads, even though we might love them to the moon and back and until the end of time, can be utterly exasperating doofuses.

My own father’s small scale doofusness took many forms. Sometimes he looked like a doofus because he wore socks with leather sandals. Not only that, but the socks were not always the same color or, for lack of elastic, they drooped around his ankles. He failed to button his often wrinkled shirts properly, prompting me to straighten him out. His salt and pepper hair had a mind if not a life of its own, refusing to be tamed by the common comb, and was almost as caricature-worthy as your own father’s unparalleled mane. That my dad didn’t look like other fathers bothered me at times. Still, his refusal to adopt a polished appearance also made me proud. As a physics professor, he preferred to think about things other than matching socks and impeccable locks. That he didn’t particularly care what impression he made gave me permission to not conform, either, and to look beyond and beneath blow dried facades to discover who a person really was.

The special bond between fathers and daughters can cause us to flinch or turn away when our dads look either like a doofus or say or do something doofus-y if not disgraceful. I often tolerated my father’s cantankerousness, his habit of referring to people who didn’t agree with him as “idiots”, and his unwillingness or inability to take other views into account. Despite the difficulties such behaviors created in my life, I eventually realized that he probably didn’t know any better than to frequently think to himself, even if not aloud, that he was smarter than others and “I alone can fix this” or “I alone have the answer”. He was raised on another continent, in another country, in a vanished culture and distant era. He lost his parents as a teenager and, despite his incredible intellect and academic credentials, lacked schooling in less caustic ways of social interaction. Still, after he passed away, I found amongst his many papers a letter from a colleague: the writer complained of my dad’s propensity to argue, his refusal to consider others’ perspective and his habit of demeaning or dismissing those who didn’t agree with him, accusations leveled at your own father.

Reading that letter broke my grieving heart even further, even though it represented just one person’s experience, not that of millions. I wanted to explain to the writer that my father, beneath his occasional outbursts, had been a sensitive soul who’d suffered unimaginable and unspeakable losses, losses which he probably hadn’t fully grieved let alone healed, losses that he coped with by, at times, lashing out in frustration. Yet I couldn’t deny the letter writer’s perspective. That he chose to reach out to my father at all indicated a basic respect and belief that greater harmony and productivity in their professional community could be possible. Most of us do not wish to be demeaned or exposed to perpetual argument.

Sometimes it takes a third party, someone we don’t know and might never meet, to draw a more accurate portrait of the people close to us. To accept that our fathers are flawed, even if deeply, doesn’t diminish the huge and complex role they play in our lives: it just makes these men human. From what I understand, your father enjoyed an early life of privilege rather than trauma, deprivation and displacement. It’s therefore hard for me to empathize with his propensity to lash out or attack the less privileged, nor do I understand what he hopes to gain from doing so, since he already seems to have more than any person could ever want.

As much as you love your father, and I don’t question your obvious affection for him, it appears that his particular if not peculiar manifestations of doofusness have tipped if not plunged into deeply distressing territory. His seemingly compulsive criticism of Mrs. Khan, the despondent mother of a fallen soldier, for remaining silent during her husband’s speech at the Democratic National Convention, has further outraged and aggrieved many people who’ve tested the limits of their patience, tolerance and blood pressure by trying to remain open minded in the face of your father’s inflammatory remarks. The Houston Chronicle, writing in its editorial page, recently referred to your dad as “a danger to the Republic.” 

To have your father so categorized by a reputable newspaper in a red state is, I imagine, embarrassing if not heartbreaking to a devoted daughter such as you. And, it presents an opportunity to have a heart to heart talk with him. Thanks to your close relationship, you have a chance to not just help with damage control but help him, and the country, heal. As his beloved daughter to whom he’s entrusted much responsibility in his business and campaign, he might listen to you more carefully than to anyone else, including his current wife. I urge you to tell him that, as much as you love him, you love your country, too, the place where you’ve thrived beyond many people’s wildest dreams and perhaps even your own. Please tell him, as my father told me, that success in life isn’t about being the best or “winning” all the time. Perhaps it’s fallen to you, in what might be the toughest if not the most terrifying act of love you’ll ever commit, to look into his eyes and tell him to back off from attacking others if not back down from the electoral contest altogether. Tell him you’ll have his back if he decides to walk away from this particular deal or, rather, ordeal.

That your father has succeeded in toppling the GOP’s “big tent” and exposing its hypocrisy has been, in the view of this independent, a service to our political system and to the future of the United States. I and others recognize this outcome, even if his tactics have made us cringe. For many, what your father has done is not just yuge but more than enough. Please, gently take him by the elbow and escort him off the national stage so he can return to minding his businesses. The fate of the free world could depend on your courage. If you take up this challenge and succeed, you might very well become the American “queen of people’s hearts”.

With respect,

Ilona Fried

[Consider donating if you enjoyed this piece. Thank you! This article is also published at The Huffington Post and at El Huffington Post (Spain)]

 

Advertisements

About ilona fried

Writer, Feldenkrais champion, Aikidoka and explorer of internal and external landscapes.

Discussion

9 thoughts on “An Open Letter to Ivanka Trump from One Daughter to Another

  1. Dear Ms. Fried your open letter to Ivanka Trump is so head on. I am glad I could read it. Your Father was a unique Person be glad that he was yours.

    Posted by Hannelore Archer | August 7, 2016, 4:59 am
  2. I think you are giving Ivanka way too much credit. She’s just like Dad, maybe a bit more discreet. She’s very scary.

    Posted by William | August 7, 2016, 12:10 pm
    • Thanks for commenting, William. Having never met her, I have no idea what she’s like, but I would like to believe that she still has a heart and is inspired by things other than brand building and the profit motive. Whether I’m right or not is not the point; I needed to express myself so as to not feel so helpless about the unfolding “ordeal”.

      Posted by ilona fried | August 7, 2016, 1:05 pm
  3. Lovely thoughts except your father suffered the worst possible thing and Donald never suffered never sacrificed never developed empathy and is not smart as your father was

    Posted by Susan silver | August 11, 2016, 9:11 am
  4. Ilona, your letter was well written and raises an interesting point of Ivanka’s potential in curbing her dad’s bigotry and meanness.

    However, I was surprised to see that you are asking people to consider making a donation to you. This was a real distraction and I’m concerned because you do not state what the donations would be used for.

    Posted by Dana Stone | February 1, 2017, 6:07 am
    • Hi Dana, Thank you for reading and leaving a comment! A few people who were moved by this letter made spontaneous donation, so I added a link to this page as well. If you visit my contribution page, you can read more about my virtual tip jar and why I set it up. In short, I have often given money to performers and other creatives to show my appreciation for their craft without caring what they will do with it. Some bloggers do the same rather than take out Google ads.

      Posted by ilona fried | February 1, 2017, 9:08 am

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Pingback: What If The “Still Small Voice” Is Neither Still Nor A Voice? – The Wisdom Daily - August 23, 2016

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to receive notifications of new posts.

Thank you!

Whether you leave a comment or a donation, I appreciate your support.

Follow on Twitter

Follow à la carte spirit by ilona fried on WordPress.com

Archives

%d bloggers like this: